Justin’s Question:
Which is more effective in today’s society: Hot or Cold?
McLuhan speaks also about “hot” and “cool” mediums. A “hot” medium is a means of communicating that provide large amounts of information and require little participation. “Cool” mediums are means of communicating that provide modest amounts of information and require much participation to be effective.
Douglas Kellner asserts that radio, television, film and the media culture at large provide us boundaries within which we may shape our identities and our places in society. How do we extract enough meaning from television, the most common form of cultural media and one that McLuhan classifies as a “cool” medium providing only modest amounts of information, to adopt meaningful identities? Would you not agree that the most media outlet with the greatest impact on society is television? Is there a “hot” medium that holds more sway?
Response:
McLuhan classifies television as a “cool” medium probably because an extreme amount of lowbrow or useless information is broadcast on so many stations. I do agree that television is, for the most part, a “cool” medium for this same reason, yet exceptions exist to every rule.
Take the many speeches, debates, and commercials that dominated the airwaves for the past two years. Much of that information was necessary for Americans to decide how to vote come November 4th. Aside from actually looking up information online, television was the only way for Americans to “connect” with presidential candidates.
Conversely, watching hours and hours of CNN’s coverage prior to the elections could be seen as more of entertainment than an actual news outlet. For some reason, news channels like CNN take a snippet of a story and then sit back and watch while a couple of “experts” make attempts to sell their case. This is hardly broadcast news, and falls under the infotainment category, not hard news.
It is ultimately up to the individual to extract meaning from television. We, as consumers, must be responsible for the content in which we allow to infiltrate our brains. And we should be able to filter out news from commentary. Unfortunately the latter is being confused for the former.
I don’t feel that a “hot” medium holds more sway. Think about it, newspaper circulation is at an all-time low in the U.S. People are receiving news from the Internet and television. Both can be incredibly useful, but should be considered subjective.
Marit’s Question:
Kellner states that minorities are still oppressed in the media. Given the tremendous growth of tolerance and free press in the country in recent years, does this still hold true?
With coverage of the struggles of minority groups and the historically overlooked, there are more channels of media open for all kinds of people. Independent newspapers and radio channels allow the people ranging from the homeless to the most exclusive wealthy, from straight-laced conservatives to the most radical liberals to express themselves. With so many opportunities, is it accurate to judge that mainstream media is closed to the "silenced and omitted"?
Response:
Kellner’s statement definitely holds true, even today. Yes, we have had expediential growth of tolerance in the media—and society in general, for that matter. But minorities are not represented as often or as fairly as whites.
Minorities are normally depicted as criminals, low-end workers, and less affluent in the mainstream media. Take the ABC show Desperate Housewives. Most of the criminal behaviors from the seediest people are not white. And, they buy into stereotypes from the Latino and Asian communities.
It is a fact (I read it in a couple text books last year) that minorities are depicted more as criminals or low lives than upstanding individuals on national television.
Independent newspapers allow for like-minded people to collaborate. Personally I don’t read Ebony magazine because nothing ever sparked my interest. Not because I don’t care about African Americans, but because the magazine is not geared toward me.
It is up to the mainstream media to fully embrace differences because specialized publications don’t bridge the gap between ethnic, political, or financial differences.
The mainstream media is currently gearing toward the sensational and celebrity. More and more real estate in newspapers is devoted to hard news stories. Instead pointless or soft stories take up space. No, the media has not completely closed off its outlet to the silenced and omitted, but less time is being spent trying to ratify social justice and more time worrying about Paris Hilton’s missing Chihuahua.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Sunday, November 2, 2008
Response to Alyssa's #3
Response to Alyssa’s blog:
Everyone has a different reality, so it can be a challenge trying to “get” into the minds of someone else. While many share the same types of realities, or groups, no individual can completely understand the reasoning of another. These individual realities are a result of many things like upbringing, religion, social status, education, and much more. One’s past experiences has a great deal to do with how they will react and which reality their mind will create.
Say for instance someone has been attacked in a parking garage when leaving work. They are most likely going to attach a particular emotion to parking garages that someone else without that experience would not have. A myriad of reactions could come into play when the attacked parks again in a garage. Or, in extreme cases, they could avoid parking garages altogether.
Creating a reality based on experience is unique to humans because we are the only species with a concept of time. Sure, a dog will eventually know that danger lurks in certain situations, but they don’t relate a cessation of that event in time. More than likely they would continue a fear of that event throughout their life. While oftentimes humans can consciously relate that time has passed and a repetition of the painful event is not likely.
Truth also comes into play because it is related to reality. One could believe that aliens have inhabited earth based on scientific research, while another could completely refute that claim. Simple sayings like “I am standing here right now” could be examined, and thus many different realities could be created.
Reality is in the eye of the individual and finding a truth or reasoning within the reality can be difficult, but looking at one’s past can provide insight into why they feel the way they do.
Everyone has a different reality, so it can be a challenge trying to “get” into the minds of someone else. While many share the same types of realities, or groups, no individual can completely understand the reasoning of another. These individual realities are a result of many things like upbringing, religion, social status, education, and much more. One’s past experiences has a great deal to do with how they will react and which reality their mind will create.
Say for instance someone has been attacked in a parking garage when leaving work. They are most likely going to attach a particular emotion to parking garages that someone else without that experience would not have. A myriad of reactions could come into play when the attacked parks again in a garage. Or, in extreme cases, they could avoid parking garages altogether.
Creating a reality based on experience is unique to humans because we are the only species with a concept of time. Sure, a dog will eventually know that danger lurks in certain situations, but they don’t relate a cessation of that event in time. More than likely they would continue a fear of that event throughout their life. While oftentimes humans can consciously relate that time has passed and a repetition of the painful event is not likely.
Truth also comes into play because it is related to reality. One could believe that aliens have inhabited earth based on scientific research, while another could completely refute that claim. Simple sayings like “I am standing here right now” could be examined, and thus many different realities could be created.
Reality is in the eye of the individual and finding a truth or reasoning within the reality can be difficult, but looking at one’s past can provide insight into why they feel the way they do.
Response To Kenny's Question #1
In response to Kenny’s question #1:
Two African American athletes, Tommy Smith and John Carlos, conducted a silent protest during the 1968 Olympics. They bowed their heads, wore black gloves and black socks without shoes. Incidentally, they were the gold and bronze medal winners. Yes, they were proud to be winning the Olympics, but felt that they could make a stance by quietly—but visibly—noting the continuation of racism in the United States.
Typically, protests are loud and breed a great deal of emotion. But by taking a quiet stance in a visible arena, these protests were able to peacefully convey a message. Their rhetoric was lost, however, on many. Smith and Carlos were booed as they left the medal stands after their protest.
An outcry of resentment began after Smith and Carlos. The Olympic committee condemned their actions and said that they were behaving in an un-Olympic manner and violating the Olympic spirit. They were also banned from the Olympic village. But is remembering from whence someone came an Olympic violation? Is making note of an ongoing problem un-Olympic? Many winning athletes thank God, mention hardships and raise awareness, yet they are not persecuted.
Often it is the medium in which people raise awareness that is criticized, not what they actually did. Combining two things like the Olympics with racial protest may spawn backlash because some feel that it was not the appropriate time to broach those subjects. These two men had the entire world as a stage and took advantage of such a large audience to raise awareness about a problem that was very important to them. While they said nothing and broke no laws, many felt that they were a disgrace to the Olympics and America. From the reactions of other athletes, onlookers and the Olympic committee, it seems as though venue and time/place of a protest has much to do with how it is received. What one is saying through body language and attire can say as much as signs or spoken words.
Two African American athletes, Tommy Smith and John Carlos, conducted a silent protest during the 1968 Olympics. They bowed their heads, wore black gloves and black socks without shoes. Incidentally, they were the gold and bronze medal winners. Yes, they were proud to be winning the Olympics, but felt that they could make a stance by quietly—but visibly—noting the continuation of racism in the United States.
Typically, protests are loud and breed a great deal of emotion. But by taking a quiet stance in a visible arena, these protests were able to peacefully convey a message. Their rhetoric was lost, however, on many. Smith and Carlos were booed as they left the medal stands after their protest.
An outcry of resentment began after Smith and Carlos. The Olympic committee condemned their actions and said that they were behaving in an un-Olympic manner and violating the Olympic spirit. They were also banned from the Olympic village. But is remembering from whence someone came an Olympic violation? Is making note of an ongoing problem un-Olympic? Many winning athletes thank God, mention hardships and raise awareness, yet they are not persecuted.
Often it is the medium in which people raise awareness that is criticized, not what they actually did. Combining two things like the Olympics with racial protest may spawn backlash because some feel that it was not the appropriate time to broach those subjects. These two men had the entire world as a stage and took advantage of such a large audience to raise awareness about a problem that was very important to them. While they said nothing and broke no laws, many felt that they were a disgrace to the Olympics and America. From the reactions of other athletes, onlookers and the Olympic committee, it seems as though venue and time/place of a protest has much to do with how it is received. What one is saying through body language and attire can say as much as signs or spoken words.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)